Traderjoe separates JOE fee sharing from liquidity provision

Keeping JOE Exposure While Receiving Fee Income

An existing JOE holding can earn protocol fee-sharing income through Avalanche's sJOE staking product. The deposit records a JOE stake without creating a position in a trading pair. Avalanche sJOE distributes its fee-sharing rewards in USDC. Your share follows the credited JOE that you hold in the staking pool relative to its total credited stake. Additional deposits by other participants can reduce that share, even when your own JOE balance stays unchanged. sJOE has no staking lock-up that forces the deposit to remain for a fixed term.

Staking doesn't require choosing price bins or maintaining a token-pair allocation. Its income still changes with the protocol fees available for distribution. Holding JOE without staking avoids this contract exposure and earns no sJOE rewards.

The Fee Streams Behind Staking and Pool Returns

Protocol Fee Sharing

The staking pool receives the protocol portion of eligible trading fees, which differs from the income allocated to liquidity providers. Liquidity Book stores a configurable protocol share for each pool, expressed as a fraction of collected swap fees. A pool's trading fee and its protocol share therefore describe different quantities.

Higher volume can increase fee collection, while fee settings and competing stakes affect the amount allocated to each staker. An annualized staking rate projects income relative to the stake's value; it doesn't promise a fixed quantity of USDC.

Pool Fees and Incentive Rewards

Joe V1 charges a swap fee of 0.3% of the input amount. Liquidity Book combines a base fee with a variable component that responds to volatility. A provider's earnings depend on the swaps using their liquidity and the provider portion of those fees.

View full-size image

Concentrated Incentives are a separate reward mechanism for eligible Liquidity Book pools. Rewards target a designated range around the active bin and follow liquidity within that range. The reward range moves with the active bin. Liquidity can qualify for incentive rewards without being in the bin that currently earns swap fees.

V1 Pools and Liquidity Book Positions

Full-Range V1 Liquidity

A V1 position supplies liquidity across the full price range, avoiding a choice of price bins. Deposits follow the pool's reserve ratio, pairing tokens at equal value using its quoted price. Equal value doesn't mean equal token quantities. This is a different commitment from depositing only JOE into sJOE.

A V1 LP token represents a proportional claim on the pool's reserves. Swaps change those reserves, so withdrawing liquidity returns the position's share of the current token balances. The deposit doesn't reserve the original quantities for later withdrawal. That changing composition affects the outcome even while trading fees accumulate.

Liquidity Book Price Ranges

Liquidity Book lets providers distribute assets across selected price bins. Liquidity Book allocates swap fees to the liquidity in the bins that a trade uses. A position outside the trading range earns no swap fees until trading reaches its bins again or its liquidity is repositioned. Wider distributions cover more price points, while narrower ones concentrate capital around fewer prices.

Moving liquidity closer to the active price can restore participation in trading. It also changes the position's market exposure and incurs transaction costs. Rebalancing itself doesn't recover losses already reflected in the position's value. The relevant comparison with sJOE is the work of managing that inventory, alongside the potential income from serving trades.

Price Exposure and Position Management

JOE staking retains JOE price exposure, even though rewards arrive in a stablecoin. Liquidity provision exposes capital to the pool assets and changes their quantities through trading. Impermanent loss is the inventory-related shortfall against holding the same starting assets outside the pool. Fees can offset that difference, but they don't automatically do so. Concentrating liquidity can intensify inventory changes over a selected range. Both routes also expose deposited assets to their respective smart contracts.

Measuring Earnings Without Counting Deposits Twice

sJOE accounting separates credited JOE principal from pending and claimed USDC rewards. Additional JOE deposits increase principal; they aren't earnings. Claimed USDC moves income into the wallet without turning it into a larger JOE stake. To assess total return, value the remaining stake and rewards in a consistent currency, then account for deposits, withdrawals, and transaction costs. The contract supports a configurable deposit fee. If that setting is nonzero, the credited JOE is less than the amount transferred. That deduction belongs among entry costs.

Pool accounting needs the current asset quantities, alongside any income held separately. V1 trading fees accumulate inside the pool's reserves. Adding an estimate of those same fees to the position's reserve value counts income twice. In Liquidity Book V2.2, provider fees remain within the relevant bin's reserves after the protocol portion is removed. Separately claimed incentive tokens require their own accounting.

The holding benchmark answers another question: how would the original asset quantities be valued at the same closing prices? Comparing that value with the liquidity position helps distinguish inventory effects from a general market rise. Additional deposits and partial withdrawals need matching treatment in both totals. A larger withdrawal value alone doesn't establish that providing liquidity outperformed holding.